Montgomery Inn Original Barbecue Sauce

(34 reviews) Write a Review

We blend tomatoes and special spices in a recipe so top-secret that only Ted’s wife Matula and her daughters know it. 


Available in the following quantities: 

  • 2 (18oz or 28oz) bottles
  • 6 (18oz or 28oz) bottles
  • 12 (18 or 28oz) bottles
Cannot be applied with any other discounts or promotions.
Enjoy your favorites delivered straight to your door at the highest quality, gauranteed. Many of the products that are available via CincyFavorites are perishable and are required to be shipped frozen. All items are hand packed in a custom cooler with dry ice to ensure they arrive in perfect condition. UPS is our primary partner for shipping and can provide a variety of shipping methods to meet your time and budget needs.

We ask that you open the order immediately upon receipt and thaw promptly, or keep frozen for later enjoyment. Failure to follow these guidelines can lead to product spoilage, which CincyFavorites cannot assume responsibility. All products delivered in a timely manner will be assumed delivered fresh and of acceptable quality. Please contact us within 3 business days of your delivery to advise of any issues or concerns.

If you use UPS My Choice and change the delivery address after your package has been shipped/while it is in transit, we are not responsible for any thawing/spoilage that may be caused by amended delivery times.

Shipping to the Continental US?
Our long-standing partnership enables us to pass along to you flat rate fees based upon the shipping method you select and the destination. Flat rate options include Ground, Air, Next Day Air Saver and 2-Day Air in eligible areas.

Shipping Outside the US or Military?
Our items can be sent via UPS Next Day Air Saver or UPS 2-Day Ground with extra dry ice to ensure that the products arrive in perfect condition. Our shipping rates are based solely on the item(s) that are being shipped and the location they are to be delivered. Additional fees (like customs) may apply. Shipping to military bases and gift cards will default to delivery via USPS in order to pass along the cost savings. If timing is an issue, UPS is an option for an additional fee. We will pass along savings whenever possible to ensure that you can ship our products at the lowest possible rate.

Orders can be cancelled up to one day before the scheduled ship day. Orders scheduled to ship the same day they are placed can be cancelled within one hour of placing the order. After this the product is committed for shipment, it cannot be cancelled. Orders cannot be cancelled once they have been committed to any point in the delivery process.

Returns Policy
CincyFavorites and its brands maintain the highest levels of quality and service. Your shipment is guaranteed to arrive in perfect condition. Our packaging and shipping protect your order, even in warmer climates. If you are not completely satisfied with your order, please Contact Us within 3 business days to explain the problem. Please do not throw the product away until you have talked with us. UPS may need to see any damages.

*No refunds will be given for circumstances beyond our control, such as weather, being given an incorrect or incomplete delivery address or if no one is available to receive the package.

34 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    The Best!

    Posted by James Buehner on Jul 19th 2020

    I live in Miami Beach Florida and have ate a lot of barbecue sauce and this is the best. I’m originally from Ohio and have eaten at Macgomery and years and years ago. Recently a friend from here asked where to eat in Cincinnati when she was visiting. I kind of forgot about the place but looked at places online is it oh yeah try this place out. She also now orders her bbq sauce from there. Its just nothing less than perfect and there’s no going back to what I was using the before!

  • 5
    Barbecue Sauce

    Posted by Paul Falck on Jul 10th 2020

    It is the BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 5
    The only sauce

    Posted by Unknown on Jun 21st 2020

    Been buying this sauce for years. The only BBQ we use!

  • 5
    Montgomery Inn Sauce

    Posted by Bobbie Wolfe on Jun 19th 2020

    I sent this to my son. He is a Sgt. In the USMC and lives in Rhode Island. Very impressed with the whole ordering process. Thank you.

  • 5

    Posted by Gerard McCoy on Jun 19th 2020

    The best barbecue sauce in the country!

  • 5
    Montgomery Inn Rib Sauce

    Posted by M E Harvey on Jun 14th 2020

    I have Loved this sauce since we lived in Ohio. My Dad was a "racing friend" O f Ted.

  • 5
    Montgomery Inn Barbecue Sauce is my all time favorite, but can’t find it in stores in Michigan. Distinct flavor with just enough sweetness. Made with excellent ingredients with no high fructose corn syrup.

    Posted by Jim Irwin on Apr 26th 2020

    Love the ability to get all the Best of Cinci

  • 5
    Montgomery Inn BBQ original sauce

    Posted by Lenora oneil on Apr 25th 2020

    Relocated to South West Florida several years ago and miss our trips to Cincy and Montgomery Inn.

  • 5
    Barbecue sauce

    Posted by Unknown on Apr 18th 2020

    It was great